/uppa-(i)/

‘to carry, move’

Language
Common Luwian
Grammar
verb
ID
2205

1. Individual Anatolian Languages

1.1 Hieroglyphic Luwian

/uppa-(i)/, (CAPERE2)u-pa-

‘to bring, send’

1.1.1Transmission

This lexeme is attested five times in inscriptions from Karkamiš, Tell Ahmar and Malatya, dating from the 10th to the 8th century BCE.

[A.P.]

1.1.2Forms

3sg. pres. ind. act. /uppai/ u-pa-i SULTANHAN, §47 (Tabal)
1sg. pret. ind. act. /uppahha/ (CAPERE2)u-pa-ha KARKAMIŠ A1a, §7 (Karkamiš)
    (CAPERE2)u-pa-ha KARKAMIŠ A1a, §10 (Karkamiš)
    (CAPERE2)u-pa-ha KARKAMIŠ A11b+c, §13 (Karkamiš)
    (“CAPERE”)u-pa-ha-i İSKENDERUN, §3 (Malatya)
    (“CAPERE”)u-pa-ha İSKENDERUN, §4 (Malatya)
    u-pa-ha TOPADA, §5 (Tabal)
3sg. pret. ind. act. /uppatta/ (CAPERE2)u-pa-ta KARKAMIŠ A2+3, §7 (Karkamiš)
    u-pa-ha SULTANHAN, §4 (Tabal)

The above list may not be complete, since the verbs /uppa-(i)/ and HLuw /uba-(i)/ ‘to found, grant’ are easily confused, especially when not preceded by a determinative and attested in semantically inconclusive contexts. In fact, the occurrence at SULTANHAN, §4 may belong to the other verb, since the context fits both meanings equally well.

[A.P.] [AH.B.]

1.1.3Graphic Features

1.1.3.1Phonological Interpretation

Because of cognates in the other Anatolian languages, the phonological interpretation of this verb is secure, and it also has a full cognate in CLuw. uppa-(i) ‘to bring’ (cf. e.g. CLL:242). However, it should be noted that, with respect to its syllabic spelling, /uppa-/ is indistinguishable from the verb /uba-(i)/ ‘to found, grant’, especially since both verbs belong to the ḫi-conjugation and therefore rely on the same set of endings. This fact has caused the verbs to be conflated from time to time by scholars, as well as varying attributions of the different attestations to one lexeme or the other, cf. e.g. Yakubovich 2005a:245 and the discussions below. Payne 2017c:109 advocates for relying on the logograms to tell the verbs apart, at least in those cases that ues any in their spelling.

[AH.B.]

1.1.4Meaning

The meaning of this verb seems reasonably clear, but mix-ups with the similarly spelt /uba-(i)/ ‘to found, grant’ have led to some confusion, and over time, scholars have suggested a host of different, albeit related meanings for this verb.E.g. ‘to carry (off)’ (Melchert 2019c:570); ‘to erect’ (Yakubovich, pers. comm.). Cf. Simon 2019i:893 for a brief summary. However, of all the meanings proposed, the contexts fit ‘to bring, send’ most easily. Melchert 2019c:572 points out that the verb possesses no inherent directionality. Instead, the verb can be combined with directional adverbs, e.g. /anta/ ‘in(to)’ and /parihha/ ‘over from’, to indicate the direction of the transfer (cf. Melchert 2004a:372).

The attestation at KARKAMIŠ A2+3, §7 illustrates the meaning well: *a-wa/i-ta *a-mi-ia-za (LITUUS.AVIS)ta-ni-ia-za REGIO-ni-i a-tá (DEUS)BONUS-na (DEUS.VITIS)ti-PRAE-ia-ha ARHA (CAPERE2)u-pa-ta, approx. /a=wa=tta ammiyanz taniyanz wattani anta Kumarman TiPariyan=ha ahha uppatta/, meaning ‘In my holdings in the land, he (scil. the storm-god Tarhunt) brought forth the (grain-god) Kumarma and (the wine-god) TiPariya’ (cf. Hawkins 2000a:109).

[AH.B.]

1.1.5Stem

The verb shows a stem in /-a-(i)/ and is considered a deradical formation, see Sasseville 2021a:363-365.Note that Sasseville 2021a:363-365 attributes the attested forms differently across the graphemically largely identical verbs /uba-(i)/ ‘to found, grant’ and /uppa-(i)/ ‘to bring, send’.

[AH.B.]

1.1.6Derivatives

  1. /uppa(n)n(i)-/

1.2 Cuneiform Luwian

ūppa-(i)

‘to carry, move’

1.2.1Transmission

The verb occurs from the Old Hittite period onward in festival texts and rituals of the Tauriša tradition.

[E.R.]

1.2.2Forms

3sg. pret. ind. act. u-up-pa-ad-da KUB 25.39 iv 18 (CTH 773, NS)
3pl. pret. ind. act. up-pa-an-t[a] KUB 35.88 iii 12’ (CTH 766, NS)
  up-pa-an-d[a] KUB 35.107 iii 21 (CTH 764, MS)
2sg. impv. act. up-pa-⸢a(=)⸣ KBo 17.36+ iv 14 (CTH 665, OS)

Tischler (in HHw:s.v.) seems to have interpreted up-pa-a=m-mi at KBo 17.36+ iv 14 as a participial form. – On ūppi-, which is sometimes classified as belonging to the present verb (e.g. tentatively in CLL:242, HEGU-Z:75), see under Lemma.

[E.R.]

1.2.3Graphic Features

Checked against the photographs in the Mainzer Fotoarchiv.

[E.R.]

1.2.4Meaning

Probably based on the similarity with the Hittite verb uppa-/-i(ya)-(ḫi) translated as ‘to bring (here)’, CLuw. ūppa-(i) was generally understood as a transfer verb indicating a movement towards the speaker, i.e. ‘to bring (here)’ (e.g. in DLL:102, HW:427,Oettinger 1979a:489, CLL:242, Melchert 2004a:370f., HEGU-Z:75, skeptical EDHIL:922, but Starke 1990a:520 n. 1921 ‘to send’). Moreover, the confusion with upa-(i) ‘to furnish, grant’ added to the philological problems around this verb. They were eventually resolved byMelchert 2004a.

While it was clear from that point onward that the Luwian verb indicates a movement, more recently, Melchert 2019a:570f. demonstrated that a directional meaning towards the speaker is synchronically not present in CLuw. ūppa-(i), as it is combined with anda ‘in, into’ specifying a third person referent. The same applies to its derivative ūppanna-(i), which is found with pariyan ‘over to’. Therefore, Melchert’s non-directional translation ‘to carry, move’ is adopted here.

[E.R.]

1.2.5Stem

Sasseville 2021a:337, 364f. puts uppa-(i) among the primary ḫi-conjugation verbs based on the Hieroglyphic-Luwian evidence.

[E.R.]

1.2.6Derivatives

  1. uppanna-(i)

1.2.6.1Uncertain Derivatives

  1. uppuppa[

2. Reconstruction

2.1Reconstruction

The equation between Hitt. uppa-/-i(ya)-(ḫi) ‘to send, bring’ (HEGU:71-76) and CLuw. ūppa-(i) ‘to carry, move’ has always been all too tempting (CLL:242) and is kept in Sasseville 2021a:364f., 426f., although certain scholars have debated this etymology on semantic grounds, see Kloekhorst (EDHIL:922) and Melchert 2019c:570f. (also on graphic grounds).

Concerning the etymology, a univerbation between the preverb u- and the verb pāi-/-i(ya)-(ḫi) ‘to give’ (see *pói̯h1-/-ih1) has been claimed for Hittite uppa-/-i(ya)-(ḫi); see Oettinger 1979a:489, Sasseville 2021a:426f. and HEGU:75f. for the literature. Differently, Melchert 2019c:569f. defends the connection with the PIE adverb *úpo (Skt. úpa ‘up to’), already suggested by Oettinger 1979a:233, 489 for a similar-sounding verb uppāi-/-i(ya)-(ḫi) ‘to raise’, whose existence is however rejected by Melchert. For the CLuw. verb ūppa-(i), on the other hand, Melchert 2019c:573 wishes to see a univerbation with a preverb related to Lat. au- ‘off’ (e.g. in auferō ‘to carry off’). Due to debated nature of these verbs, no reconstruction is offered here.

See also CLuw. ūppi- and CLuw. ūpnalla/i- and potential cognates for the root in Lyc. A upahi, ]upezide and Lyc. B uple(/i)-.

[D.S.]

Cross-references