/warwalan(a)-/

‘seed, progeny’

Language
Common Luwian
Grammar
subst, n.
ID
1512

1. Individual Anatolian Languages

1.1 Hieroglyphic Luwian

/warwala(n)-/, (“*471”)u!-ru-wa/i-tà-

‘seed’

1.1.1Transmission

This noun is attested once in an inscription from Tell Ahmar, dating to the late 10th or early 9th century BCE.

[AH.B.]

1.1.2Forms

nom./acc. sg. /urwalan=za/ (“*471”)u!-ru-wa/i-tà-za ALEPPO 2, §16 (Tell Ahmar)

The reading of the first phonetic sign in ALEPPO 2, §16 follows Meriggi (HHG:139). Hawkins 2000a:236 tentatively reads 〈(“*471”)(m)u?-ru-wa/i-tà-za〉, but from the photograph it cannot be said with certainty that the first sign is 〈mu〉 (*107) and not 〈u〉 (*105). The signs only differ in *107 containing four short vertical strokes within the shape of *105, tying it to the range of the M-signs. Because of the connection with the GKW warwalan(a)- ‘seed, progeny’, the reading of the sign as 〈u〉 is preferable, which Hawkins 2000a:238 also mentions.

[AH.B.]

1.1.3Graphic Features

1.1.3.1Phonological Interpretation

The phonological interpretation of this lexeme has been a matter of debate among scholars for a number of years van Brock 1962a:105 posits for CLuw. a heteroclitic stem *warwatar, *warwatn-, followed by Starke 1990a:479-484 and Oettinger 1995b:49. Their view was contested by Otten 1988a:105 and Melchert in CLL:261., not least because the spelling of the direct CLuw. cognate warwalan(a)- is rather less than clear in some instances, see the discussion in HEG W-Z:375f. However, other etymologically related words support the current stem interpretation, and the HLuw. evidence fits fully into it. In the HLuw. attestation in ALEPPO 2, §16, the use of 〈tà〉 (sign *41) for /da/ instead of any of any of the LA signs is due to rhotacism (see Melchert 2003b:179-182 and Rieken & Yakubovich 2010a:216f.). It represents a case of hypercorrection in which a spoken flap /ɾ/ resulting from the merger of intervocalic /r, l, d/ was erroneously traced back to /d/ instead of /l/.

[AH.B.]

1.1.4Meaning

Despite only a single attestation, the meaning of the noun is clear, both because of its cognate link with CLuw. warwalan(a)- ‘seed’ as well as its context of attestation in HLuw. In ALEPPO 2, §16, the relevant clause is part of the apodosis of the curse formula: (“TERRA”)ta-sà-kwa/i+ra/i-ti-pa-wa/i-ta (“*471”)u!-ru-wa/i-tà-za ní-i SUPER+ra/i-a PES-wa/i-ti, approx. /taskwaradi=ba=wa=tta urwalan=za ni sarra awidi/, meaning ‘The seed shall not come up for him (scil. whoever damages the installation) from the earth!’

[AH.B.]

1.1.5Stem

The shape of the stem is assumed to be /warwala(n)-/, tallying with the CLuw. evidence for the word (CLL:261 with discussion), which is based on the CLuw. equivalent. Outdated is Rieken 2008b:645, who analysed the stem as ending in the suffix /-ada-/, which is theoretically possible. However, in the face of the CLuw. evidence for warwalan(a)-, it is more economical to assume that a hypercorrection has taken place, cf. the discussion in the phonological interpretation above.

[AH.B.]

1.2 Cuneiform Luwian

warwalan(a)-

‘seed, progeny’

1.2.1Transmission

Within the Cuneiform Luwian corpus, the word is transmitted only as a logogram, occurring in the Puriyanni ritual and the Kuwattalla tradition (from MS onwards).

[E.R.]

1.2.2Forms

nom./acc. sg. NUMUN-an KUB 35.21 obv. 25’ (CTH 761, MS)
nom./acc. pl. NUMUNḪI.A-n[a] KUB 35.54 ii 31’ (CTH 758, MS)
  [NUM]UNḪI.A-˹na˺ KBo 29.2 ii 9’ (CTH 758, MS)

1.2.3Graphic Features

1.2.3.1Phonological Interpretation

On account of the parallel contexts of gen. sg. NUMUN-aš ‘of the seed, of the progeny’ and dat./loc. sg. doppelter Glossenkeilwarwalani (at KBo 4.10 obv. 11’ and rev. 24f., respectively), Sommer (Sommer 1922a:58 n. 1) tentatively suggested that doppelter Glossenkeilwarwalananteš should be translated as ‘Nachkommenschaft’. Later, the similarity of the Cuneiform signs LA and AT prompted a new discussion with respect to the reading of the syllabic spelling (warwatn- or warwalan-), which was relevant for the reading of the logogram as well, and it was decided in favor of warwalan-. The most cogent argument for LA is the fact that the nom./acc. pl. n. of a stem in -attar/-at(ta)n- ends in -at(ta)ra, rather than **-at(ta)na as attested indirectly by NUMUNḪI.A-n[a] (see HEG U-Z:375-378, where the history of research is reported, and under Lemma doppelter Glossenkeil/Glossenkeilwar(ru)walan(a)-, Graphic Features with references).

[E.R.]

1.2.4Meaning

For the meaning, see under doppelter Glossenkeil/Glossenkeilwar(ru)walan(a)-.

[E.R.]

1.2.5Stem

For a dicussion of the stem, see under doppelter Glossenkeil/Glossenkeilwar(ru)walan(a)-.

[E.R.]

1.3 Luwian (Glossenkeilwörter)

doppelter Glossenkeil/Glossenkeilwar(ru)walan(a)-

‘seed, progeny’

1.3.1Transmission

The syllabic spelling is limited to New Hittite historical texts, while logographic attestations may well belong to a cognate or entirely different Hittite lexeme. The attestation of the lexeme without gloss wedges occurs exclusively in the NS Bronze Tablet.

[E.R.]

1.3.2Forms

gen. sg. Glossenkeil˹wa˺-ar-ru-wa-la-˹na˺-aš KUB 21.37, 13’ (CTH 85, NS)
dat./loc. sg. doppelter Glossenkeilwa-ar-wa-la-ni KBo 4.10 rev. 22, 24 (CTH 106, NS)
  wa-ar-wa-la-ni Bo 86/299 iii 2, 6, 16, iv 24 (CTH 106, NS)
erg. sg. doppelter Glossenkeilwa-ar-wa-la-na-an-te-eš KBo 4.10 rev. 25 (CTH 106, NS)

DLL:108 and HEG U-Z:375 list doppelter Glossenkeilwa-ar-wa-la-na-an-te-eš as nom. pl. Kronasser’s   (Kronasser 1962b:216) interpretation that “damit die wirksame Kraft zum Ausdruck komm[t], daß eben nur bestimmte Nachkommen (des Ulmitešup) die Herrschaft haben sollen” is of little help. However, unless the singular verb of the clause ḫardu features one of the very rare cases of semantic agreement, the subject warwalananteš has to be classified as a singular form (with i-mutation) as well (thus CLL:261).

[E.R.]

1.3.3Graphic Features

Due to the similarity of the Cuneiform signs LA and AT, the reading of the gloss wedge word (doppelter Glossenkeilwa-ar-wa-at-n° or doppelter Glossenkeilwa-ar-wa-la-n°) was discussed up until the 1990s (see HEG U-Z:375-378, where the history of research is reported). However, an n-stem warwalan- seems to be accepted now (DLL:108, HW:247, CLL:261, HEG U-Z:375, HHw:197, EDHIL:980, Ünal 2007a:792). Support comes from the related derivative DWarwaliya- with -l- (CLL:262) and the nom./acc. pl. n. NUMUN-na, built on a stem ending in -n- (EDHIL:980) or -na- (see under Stem), but incompatible with a stem in **-attar/-at(ta)n- (suggested by van Brock 1962a:105, followed in Starke 1990a:479-484, van den Hout 1995a:20 and 26, Oettinger 1995b:49), whose plural would have ended in -at(ta)ra, instead.

[E.R.]

1.3.4Meaning

Based on the switch within KBo 4.10 (obv. 11’ and rev. 24f.), doppelter Glossenkeilwarwalani was recognized as the syllabic equivalent of NUMUN ‘seed, progeny’ already in 1922 by Sommer 1922a:58 n. 1. Further confirmation was offered later by parallel passages in the Ulmi-Teššup treaty (KBo 4.10 rev. 21-25) and the Bronze Tablet (Bo 86/299 iii 1-6, iii 14-16, iv 23f.), see the list in Starke 1990a:481. The meaning as given has entered the handbooks: DLL:108, HW:247, Starke 1990a:479, CLL:261, HEG U-Z:375, HHw:s.v., EDHIL:980, Ünal 2007a:792.

[E.R.]

1.3.5Stem

It is generally agreed that the stem (or, in the case of Starke 1990a:479, at least the oblique stem) ends in -n-. In principle, also a neuter a-stem war(ru)walan(a)- with nom./acc. sg. n. war(ru)walanan is possible as well. Neither proposal is attractive from the point of view of the history of stem formation, but since Luwian neuter stems with -an- suffix are disyllabic and, therefore, probably primary derivatives, war(ru)walan(a)- is favored here and analyzed as warwa-la-n(a)-.

[E.R.]

1.3.6Origin

A Luwian origin is suggested by the use of gloss wedges in several instances and the use of i-mutation, as well as the existence of a Hieroglyphic Luwian cognate, i.e. (“*471”)u!-ru-wa/i-tà-za /w(a)rwalanza/. In addition to the literature already cited in this lemma entry, see Melchert 2005a:450f. and van den Hout 2006a:240.

[E.R.]

For the lemma head see CLuw. *warwa/i-.

Cross-references

Referred to from this article

Articles referring here